Search this site

Search publications, legal cases, projects and news.

Reports

Issues identified in Armenia’s functional assessment system

Cover of DRA’s list of issues in the functional assessment system, displayed on a tablet against a blue background.

Disability Rights Agenda has compiled a list of issues identified in Armenia’s functional assessment system, drawing on its monitoring of assessment sessions and observations gathered through its work.

We submitted the document to Members of Parliament during the working discussion held on 10 November 2026. Mushegh Hovsepyan presented DRA’s findings at the meeting.

The document covers eleven areas: medical referrals; applications and information systems; assessment arrangements and deadlines; assessment commissions; assessment methodology and participation; administrative decisions and evidence; administrative and judicial appeals; individual service plans; governance and accountability; additional findings from observed sessions; and reassessment methodology.

It identifies procedural and accessibility barriers and proposes improvements to participation, transparency, accountability and access to services.

The full English translation is provided below. You can also download the original Armenian document in Word format.

Read about the parliamentary discussion.

I. Contacting a medical organisation and obtaining a referral

  • Diagnoses and examination results from medical organisations abroad are not always accepted, forcing people to repeat examinations in Armenia.
  • The reasons for rejecting referrals are often insufficiently explained, leaving the referring doctor to guess which information is incorrect. Doctors do not have contact details for people who can explain the problems and help them correct the referral.
  • The procedure for challenging a medical organisation’s refusal or failure to issue a referral is not sufficiently clear or accessible to the person concerned.
  • People are forced to repeat examinations already carried out because of problems with information exchange and trust between medical organisations.
  • Incorrect or incomplete referrals issued by medical organisations delay the assessment process.
  • The procedure for correcting technical or factual errors in a referral without restarting the process is not sufficiently streamlined.
  • Accountability mechanisms for medical organisations that unjustifiably refuse, delay or incorrectly complete referrals need clarification.
  • There are insufficient safeguards allowing a person to initiate the assessment process when a medical organisation unjustifiably withholds a referral.
  • A person may have to repeat the referral process when the referral expires because of administrative delays beyond their control.
  • In practice, home visits by medical organisations are limited to visits by a family doctor, meaning that people unable to leave home must pay for a specialist’s visit.
  • People with clearly serious health conditions who have not yet been recognised as persons with disabilities and are not covered for the relevant free medical examinations may be unable to afford the examinations required for assessment.
  • Diagnoses and conclusions issued by specialised medical institutions abroad for people with rare or multiple conditions are not always accepted, even when the relevant diagnostic services are unavailable in Armenia or the condition resulted from a medical error.

II. Applications and information systems

  • The detection and correction of errors in data transfers between the Armed and e-disability systems, and responsibility for those errors, are not regulated clearly enough.
  • People cannot always track their application, identify who is responsible or find out when the next step will take place.
  • Procedures for correcting deficiencies in documents can lead to unnecessary repeat applications and delays in assessment.
  • Corrections to medical and other personal data need to be simplified, with changes transferred between systems.
  • Rules for accepting applications, calculating deadlines and continuing the process during information system outages need clarification.
  • E-disability.am still does not meet Level AA of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines. The organisation will submit its detailed findings on this issue again.

III. Assessment arrangements and deadlines

  • Assessments are not always organised, or administrative decisions adopted, within the prescribed 30-day period following an application.
  • Mechanisms to protect a person’s rights and hold the responsible authority accountable when an assessment is delayed are not sufficiently effective.
  • People are sometimes notified of their assessment only one day in advance, preventing adequate preparation. This also hinders the participation of civil society organisations.
  • An adequate minimum notice period for the date and time of an assessment needs to be established.
  • Assessment notifications are not always provided in an accessible format or through the person’s preferred means of communication; they are usually made by telephone.
  • Procedures for changing the assessment date or postponing it at a person’s justified request need clarification.
  • Deadlines for arranging and conducting an assessment at the person’s location are not clearly defined.
  • Refusals to conduct an assessment at a person’s location must be reasoned and subject to an effective appeal.
  • The procedure for continuing the process when a person is hospitalised, their health deteriorates or they cannot attend for a valid reason needs clarification.

IV. Formation and operation of assessment commissions

  • Because the register includes only a limited number of specialists, the same commission members are frequently appointed together, weakening the anti-corruption purpose of rotation.
  • Cases have been recorded in which administrative decisions were signed by commission members who did not actually participate in the assessment.
  • Commission members do not always introduce themselves or explain their names, professional specialisms and roles to the person being assessed.
  • The procedure for documenting and resolving differing professional opinions among commission members needs clarification.
  • Commissions rarely use their power to refer people for additional medical examinations, even when the available information may be insufficient.
  • Cases have been recorded in which a person’s health condition was dismissed or the person was treated with distrust from the outset.
  • Mechanisms for examining complaints about inappropriate conduct by commissions and ensuring accountability are not sufficiently effective.
  • The effective participation of a support person, representative or communication support professional chosen by the person being assessed must be ensured. Cases have been recorded in which a commission did not allow the person’s companion to remain in the room.

V. Assessment methodology and the person’s participation

  • People are not always given a meaningful opportunity to describe their own experiences, views and individual needs and have them taken into account during assessment.
  • Medical information may dominate the assessment at the expense of an actual examination of the person’s activities, participation and environmental barriers.
  • It is not sufficiently clear how medical documents, the person’s explanations and other professional opinions should be considered together.
  • The procedure for resolving conflicting medical opinions and inconsistencies between those opinions and assessment results needs clarification.
  • The facts, objections and explanations presented by the person must be fully recorded and considered.
  • Clear requirements are needed for documenting the assessment process, questions asked, responses, observations and professional conclusions.
  • People cannot sufficiently understand and verify how individual scores are translated into the final result.
  • It must be possible to independently reproduce and verify an assessment result using the same data and methodology.
  • A history of changes to the formulas and software system must be retained so that the version applied to each decision can be identified.
  • The commission’s responsibilities and powers to verify calculations and detect and correct errors need clarification.
  • The methodology should be regularly evaluated to determine whether it has disproportionate or discriminatory effects on persons with different types of disabilities.
  • At the end of the assessment, the person is not always informed of the final decision, and their preferred method of notification is not always respected.

VI. Administrative decisions, documentation and evidence

  • Decisions do not always disclose the factual basis for each score, the criteria applied or the reasoning behind the final result.
  • People must have access to their complete administrative assessment file, including records, calculations and the documents used.
  • Procedures for accessing and obtaining audiovisual recordings of assessments are not regulated clearly enough.
  • The retention periods for audiovisual recordings, safeguards for their integrity, access restrictions and destruction procedures need clarification.
  • Practical safeguards for submitting and using audiovisual recordings of assessments as evidence in administrative and judicial proceedings need clarification.
  • The procedure for correcting errors in assessment documents and calculations without repeating the entire assessment is not sufficiently streamlined.
  • It must be possible to trace every action taken during an assessment, changes to data and the people responsible.

VII. Administrative and judicial appeals

  • Effective challenges must be available for procedural violations as well as for the final assessment result.
  • The procedure for submitting and examining additional medical documents, expert opinions and other evidence during an appeal needs clarification.
  • A genuine opportunity for independent professional review of assessment results must be ensured, including in judicial proceedings.
  • Administrative courts do not always effectively apply the principle of establishing the facts of a case on their own initiative in functional assessment disputes.
  • The length of judicial proceedings and the specialised nature of assessments may prevent a person from obtaining timely and effective legal protection.
  • The point at which social security and other rights are restored, and the procedure for doing so, need clarification when the original assessment decision is overturned or amended.
  • A distinction must be made between cases requiring an entirely new assessment and those in which reviewing individual scores or factual errors is sufficient.

VIII. Individual service plans

  • Individual service plans do not always reflect a person’s actual needs and may be limited to standard recommendations.
  • Individual service plans often omit services that a person needs but that are currently unavailable, preventing the state from obtaining a complete picture of needs.
  • There is no sufficiently effective, unified mechanism for collecting data on unmet needs and using it in service development and budget planning.
  • People are often required to attend in person again to add a new service or change an existing one, even when their presence is unnecessary.
  • Accessible electronic or alternative procedures must be provided for amending plans without unnecessary physical attendance.
  • The responsibilities of the authorities responsible for organising, providing and achieving the intended outcome of each planned service are not sufficiently clear.
  • Clear deadlines, or a transparent mechanism for setting them, must be established for the provision of services included in individual service plans.
  • Including a guaranteed service in an individual service plan does not itself guarantee its actual provision, and the consequences of non-provision are not addressed effectively enough.
  • Regular oversight of the implementation of individual service plans, service quality and the extent to which a person’s needs are met is not sufficiently effective.
  • Effective challenges must be available against decisions to omit a necessary service from a plan, change a service or refuse to provide it.

IX. Governance, oversight and accountability

  • The division of functions among authorities responsible for different assessment stages may result in no authority being accountable for the outcome of the process as a whole.
  • Data on the duration of each stage, delays, returned applications, errors and appeals are not collected and analysed systematically enough.
  • Regular analysis is needed of the reasoning and consistency of commission decisions, appeals and decisions that have been overturned.
  • Mechanisms for identifying and eliminating recurring methodological, technical and administrative errors are not sufficiently effective.
  • A mechanism is needed to review the decisions of people affected by the same error without requiring each person to bring separate judicial proceedings.
  • Effective oversight of access to, use of and changes to medical and other sensitive data must be ensured. The system must log all access.
  • All rules that materially affect a person’s rights and assessment results must be set out in appropriate legal instruments, published and accessible to the public.

X. Additional issues identified through observation of assessment sessions

  • Before an assessment begins, the person is not always given a full explanation of the process, its stages and the methods used.
  • During the assessment, the person is not always informed of their right to appeal, the procedure or the deadlines.
  • The person is not always informed when and how they will receive the assessment decision and individual service plan.
  • Assessment professionals do not always review the self-assessment questionnaire completed by the person or properly take its findings into account.
  • Some buildings used for assessments have physical barriers, including doors that are difficult to open independently.
  • Some waiting rooms at assessment sites have insufficient space, lighting and seating and do not provide comfortable and dignified conditions for people waiting.
  • Assessment sessions frequently start later than scheduled, causing unnecessary waiting and difficulties for the people attending.
  • People who are not involved in the assessment have been observed entering and leaving during sessions, potentially compromising privacy and disrupting the assessment.

XI. Additional issues concerning methodology and reassessment

  • Inconsistencies between functional limitations recorded by different professionals are not always identified, explained and resolved before the final decision is adopted.
  • The justification for differing requirements to establish disability status without a time limit after the first, third or fifth assessment needs to be reviewed, taking into account the stability of the condition and the need for reassessment.
  • Unnecessary periodic reassessments must be avoided when the stability and irreversibility of functional limitations have already been sufficiently established.
  • The assessment methodology must account for the combined impact of impairments affecting different organs and systems, rather than being limited to individual diagnoses.
  • It needs to be clarified how the effects of conditions with recurring exacerbations and periods of remission on a person’s daily activities and participation are assessed.
  • Prescribed periods of treatment or rehabilitation must not become unjustified barriers for people whose functional limitations can already be assessed.

Accessible formats

Reports and accompanying documents may not be fully accessible to all persons with disabilities. If you need an alternative format, email info@dra.am.

External links open in a new window. External websites may also present accessibility barriers.


Discover more from Disability Rights Agenda

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.