The historic decision of the Constitutional Court was published
The Constitutional Court recognized as unconstitutional and invalid the provisions of the RA Government’s decision that imposed an absolute ban on deaf or blind people becoming judges.
The court noted that such general prohibitions violate the constitutional right to access public service and contradict the principle of proportionality. At the same time, it stated that it is the government’s prerogative to establish a list of diseases, but an individualized approach should be applied in each case.
The abilities of a candidate judge should be assessed not by the fact of disability, but by his or her ability to ensure the effective administration of justice.
This was an important step in terms of recognizing the rights of people with disabilities. Our more detailed position on the decision will be discussed later.
You can read the decision here:Related materialIt may not be fully accessible to people with visual impairments.
It should be recalled that the RA Human Rights Defender had applied to the Constitutional Court. The “Disability Rights Agenda” NGO had submitted a friendly brief and the testimony of retired US judge David S. Teitle to the Constitutional Court, which were used in the references of the decision.
We are grateful to Hogan Lovells for their legal assistance in the preparation of this brief. We are also grateful to the non-governmental organization PILnet for facilitating this valuable collaboration.
Discover more from Disability Rights Agenda
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
