Search this site

Search publications, legal cases, projects and news.

News

Joint statement on the new change in the disability definition system

Joint statement on the new change in the disability definition system

Government of June 27by decisionmade changes and additions to the procedure for assessing a person’s functionality.

According to the amendment, if a person wants to have an individual service plan and receive the services derived from it, they must go through the disability determination process again. The individual service plan (ISP) includes guarantees of the medical, rehabilitation, educational, vocational, social services and activities and support measures needed by the person.

In other words, a person whose disability was determined by the previous medical and social examination system must go through the disability determination process again in order to receive certain assistive devices or services. As a result, the person’s disability group (now the functional assessment level) may change or disability may not be determined at all, and consequently the amount of disability benefit and other guarantees provided to the person may also change.

This can force people with disabilities to make a choice between two important rights: the right to have their disability recognized and the right to access necessary services.

With this amendment, the state effectively renounces the obligations implied by administrative acts in force (including those with no time limit), violating people’s right to legitimate expectations.

Assuming the purpose of this change, we can argue that the change will in no way contribute to the removal of people with disabilities with false documents from the system. These people, not needing services, will not apply for an individual service program, continuing to benefit from state guarantees. And those people who, for example, need any services, will have to go through the disability determination process again. In all cases, it should be borne in mind that corruption prevention activities must be balanced and respect the rights of people with disabilities.

When discussing the amendment, the government was obliged to ensure the meaningful participation of persons with disabilities and their representative organizations, which was not done. As previously noted by UN Special Rapporteurs during their communication with the government, conducting a public discussion only through e-draft.am does not meet the requirements of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.

The Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs of the Republic of Armenia, as the submitter of the draft, also violated the requirement to send draft normative legal acts related to human rights to the Human Rights Defender of the Republic of Armenia for an opinion.

In addition to violating numerous legal requirements, the government should have taken several factors into account when considering the amendment, including:

  • The process of determining disability is time-consuming and can be stressful, also taking into account individuals’ previous negative experiences.
  • The change does not make things easier, but rather places an additional burden on people with disabilities.
  • The change does not contribute to the timely provision of necessary services to the person and their easy access.
  • There is low awareness of the new assessment system so that people with disabilities can easily make decisions.
  • The new system is extremely non-transparent and does not comply with the human rights approach to disability.

We, organizations and individuals engaged in the protection of the rights of persons with disabilities, believe that the decision reduces trust in public authorities and the decisions they make, violates the constitutional right to proper administration, and causes discrimination on the basis of disability.

We call on the Armenian government to repeal the decision.

Signatories:

  • “Disability Rights Agenda” NGO
  • “We Can” NGO for the protection of the interests of young people, children and their families with mental disabilities
  • “Agat” Center for the Protection of the Rights of Women with Disabilities NGO
  • “Lusastgh” NGO
  • Equal Education Foundation
  • “Equal Rights, Equal Opportunities” NGO for People with Disabilities
  • “Path to Equality” NGO
  • Sipan Asatryan
  • Arevik Melkonyan
  • Narine Ghukasyan
  • Vahan Dishlanyan
  • Vahan Sargsyan
  • Hayk Mkrtchyan
  • Lusine Ghazaryan
  • Karine Stepanyan

 


Discover more from Disability Rights Agenda

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.