Search this site

Search publications, legal cases, projects and news.

Public positions

Announcement on changes to the list of diseases determining the degree of fitness for military service

Announcement on changes to the list of diseases determining the degree of fitness for military service

On April 18, 2024, the RA Government implemented a number of changes in the list of diseases that determine the degree of fitness of a citizen or soldier for military service.

According to the decision, individuals with bedwetting in the ranks of privates and junior non-commissioned officers of compulsory military service will be subject to restricted military service.

Some individuals with “mild mental retardation”* will also be subject to restricted service. This list includes:“states of intellectual deficiency and pedagogical retardation, mild, other mental and unspecified mental retardation, not accompanied by behavioral or adjustment disorders, […] as well as problems related to teaching and literacy (low literacy level, primitiveness of the personality).”

As a justification, the draft states that the statistics for the aforementioned health conditions have increased. For example, “the number of conscripts recognized as unfit for compulsory military service with a diagnosis of “mental retardation” has increased from conscription to conscription, in particular, if during the 2020 summer conscription 188 conscripts were recognized as unfit with the aforementioned diagnosis, then during the 2022 winter conscription it amounted to 321.”

From the oral discussion at the government session, it can also be assumed that these amendments aim to reduce cases of document forgery.

We, organizations working on issues of persons with disabilities, express our concern regarding these changes, which put the rights of persons with actual health problems at risk.

Corruption prevention efforts must take into account the rights and needs of everyone, including people with health problems. When implementing anti-corruption measures, it is important to ensure that they do not inadvertently harm those who are already marginalized or disadvantaged.

In this case, the solution to the problem of exemption from the army with false medical documents is not limited service for everyone, including those who actually have these health problems, but a review of mechanisms that will reduce the possibility of exemption from the army with false documents without harming others.

We are also concerned that no recommendations and observations on this draft have been submitted by the Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs of the Republic of Armenia, which coordinates the work of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities in the country. Also, according to the summary, no recommendations have been received by the Human Rights Defender of the Republic of Armenia, which in turn is responsible for monitoring the Convention, within the established deadlines.

These changes are not justified, do not reflect the reality of military service (limited or not) and the obligations assumed by the State under the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, including the elimination of discrimination on the basis of disability. The UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, in its General Comment No. 6, states that States parties should “provide special protection to prevent and remedy cases of violence, exploitation and abuse and violations of physical integrity that are unique or disproportionately experienced by persons with disabilities, and exercise due diligence.”

The government’s decision does not take into account the fact that even if the above-mentioned health conditions are minor or asymptomatic, they can affect military service and have a high risk of deterioration under the physical and psychological stress typical of the military environment.

There are a number of other circumstances that should have been a decisive factor in making this decision, namely:

1. Bedwettingcan create virtually insurmountable difficulties during service, where living conditions may be cramped and access to laundry and bathrooms limited. Difficulties in maintaining personal hygiene, including bed cleanliness, can increase the risk of skin infections and other hygiene-related health problems. In such conditions, bedwetting can affect not only the individual, but also others sharing the same environment.

The stigma surrounding bedwetting can also affect a person’s psychological well-being. The stress of managing bedwetting in such an environment can lead to sleep disturbances, decreased self-esteem, fear and anxiety, including feeling isolated and exposed to humiliating situations.

2. People with mild intellectual disabilities without behavioral problemsLimited military service is also high-risk. Military service, including limited military service, requires rapid adaptation and the ability to learn. Some individuals with intellectual disabilities may have difficulty in environments where instructions and tasks are complex and change rapidly. Some individuals may have difficulty fully understanding oral and written instructions that are not readily available (ambiguous, complex, etc.). Misunderstandings or difficulties with orientation, especially in stressful situations, can increase safety risks, first of all, for the individual. All of this, including interpersonal relationships, can also be affected by pharmacological intervention, which may be necessary not only for behavioral disorders, but also for various mood or cognitive circumstances.

In various social settings that are built on abilities, including the military, there are many stereotypes and stigmas. People with mild intellectual disabilities may face exclusion due to differences and difficulties arising from different abilities or pace of functioning. For example, this may manifest itself in being excluded from group activities, discussions, or decision-making processes.

There is a high risk of bullying, harassment, sexual and physical violence. Individuals may be more vulnerable to exploitation, such as being forced to take on unwanted responsibilities or being manipulated because they do not understand the intentions of others. This exploitation may also be financial in nature, such as giving up their income or other goods.

In terms of guaranteeing the rights of people with these health problems, conditions in the army are absent or insufficient, even in the case of limited military service.

Before resolving this issue, the government should have made efforts to comprehensively study the issues and verify the necessary minimum conditions. For example, the systematic assessment of individualized health monitoring and rapid response capabilities during service, the possibility of introducing procedures to ensure reasonable accommodations during limited military service, etc.

We call on the government to review the list, taking into account all the above risks and the rights of all persons with health problems. We also remind you that projects with such an impact should be adopted as a result of broad discussions, including the direct participation of all affected persons, and not limited to the publication of projects on e-draft.am.

Signatories:

1. “Disability Rights Agenda” NGO

2. “We Can” NGO for the protection of the interests of young people, children and their families with mental disabilities

3. “Agat” NGO

4. “Equal Rights, Equal Opportunities” NGO for People with Disabilities

Government decision

* The statement used wording that we do not encourage, but we were forced to use in order not to make the statement vulnerable from a legal perspective. We encourage the use of terms that respect human dignity and do not reinforce existing stereotypes in society or create new ones.


Discover more from Disability Rights Agenda

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.