Everyone in the Italian neighborhood of Spitak knows Vahagn. A tall, dark-skinned, thick-haired young man who speaks 4 languages and wears amazing amulets. Anyone in the neighborhood who has a computer problem immediately calls Vahagn. They know that there is no problem he cannot solve. In the process,
He will tell amazing stories from India, Africa, and other parts of the world where he has been.

Vahagn is easy to find. He is always in the same place: at the Spitak nursing home, where he has lived for 5 years. Today, the big world Vahagn has seen is limited to the small yard of the nursing home.
“I was born in Yerevan. After my parents divorced, when I was 2 years old, my mother took us to Akhltskha. When I was 14, we moved to Moscow with my mother, sister, grandmother, and uncle. My first profession is a paramedic-laboratory assistant, with a secondary vocational medical education.
“I have. Then I was admitted to the Komsomol Higher School, Faculty of Psychology, but my education, unfortunately, remained incomplete. In the late 1990s, my mother faced serious financial problems, and education was paid,” Vahagn recalls.

Despite this, Vahagn Petrosyan was hired by the Moscow Helsinki Group as an assistant director. The sociable, developed, intellectually humorous young man was sure that the world was big and beautiful, like in the books he read, and that it needed to be seen. A chance acquaintance took Vahagn to India, where he lived for about 1.5 years and managed to study in meditation centers.
After returning to Moscow, Vahagn first appeared in a psychiatric hospital for undressing in a public place.
“Before that, I had lived for 1.5 months on a ‘wild beach’ where everyone walked around naked. It was a habit,” he says.

From Moscow to Sevan, then to Vardenis. Vahagn lived in psychiatric hospitals for about 5 years, after which he was moved to a nursing home in Spitak. Here he has his own room and telephone, and he reads a lot. Recently, he has been studying the Bible with interest. On a small shelf next to the bed, a thick selection of Jack London awaits his turn.
For Vahagn, who has lived in different corners of the world, however, the center of the world is his father’s village, Hovk, in the Tavush region.
“My father has a small house in the village, with a plot of land. If it turns out that my father doesn’t sell it, he promised to leave it to me. Here they taught me to work with the land. My biggest dream is to live in that house in Hovk, to wake up at my own time in the morning, to cultivate the land, and just live. And if someone appears who will love me, to also have a family. I want to go to Ireland, travel, and become a vegetarian. I have a friend in Moscow who has cancer, I want to see him one last time. I don’t want much, do I?” asks Vahagn.
Vahagn’s simple dreams, however, will not come true for one reason: he has been declared incompetent. This means that Vahagn’s life is predetermined: instead of him, others decide where he lives, what he eats, when he sleeps and wakes up, the length of his hair, and whether he can love and miss.
Vahagn was declared incompetent based on his father’s application. He says that according to his father, it was the only option to place him in an institution and provide him with the necessary care, although he never agreed with that decision. He is still a little upset with his father, but he tries to understand him.
In the Republic of Armenia, 1,454 adult citizens are currently being treated or receiving care in psychiatric and care institutions, 397 of whom have been recognized as incompetent. About 1/3 of them are under the age of 25.
The legislation of the Republic of Armenia recognizes the rights, freedoms and obligations of all persons and the right to equality before the law without any discrimination. In particular, according to the Civil Code of the Republic of Armenia, the ability of persons to have civil rights and bear obligations is recognized equally for all citizens, which arises from their birth and ceases with death. However, the current legislation of the Republic of Armenia does not equally recognize and protect the right of persons with mental health and mental disorders to equality before the law in all spheres of life. Article 31 of the Civil Code of the Republic of Armenia provides that a citizen who, as a result of a mental disorder, cannot understand the meaning of his actions or direct them, may be recognized by the court as incompetent. Guardianship is established for him. Under such legislative regulations, a person with mental health or mental disorders may be deprived of his right to legal capacity by the court without any alternative. In particular, the legislation of the Republic of Armenia does not provide for the possibility of partial restriction of the right to legal capacity for persons with mental health or mental disorders, as well as support mechanisms that do not imply restriction of the right to legal capacity.The legislation of the Republic of Armenia provides for the possibility of recognizing persons with mental health and intellectual disabilities as incompetent, depriving them of the right to make decisions in matters concerning themselves. Depriving a person of incompetence has negative consequences on a number of their rights, including the rights to marital and family relations, the right to health, as well as freedom and personal immunity, participation in political and public life, possession and disposal of property and financial resources, and other rights. Moreover, incompetence deprives a person of the right to access the court, depriving them of the opportunity to apply to the court without an intermediary, jeopardizing the protection of other rights.
Mental health law specialist Anahit Chilingaryan says that in essence, Armenian legislation allows people with mental health problems to be recognized as incompetent, which deprives a person of the opportunity to independently exercise many of their rights. These are mainly those rights that are directly related to our daily actions, everyday life, such as property rights, managing money, rights related to marital and family relations, such as marriage, divorce or adoption of a child. To put it simply, a person recognized as incompetent cannot register a marriage, and the incompetence of one of the spouses can lead to divorce without taking into account his will. But depriving a person of a number of his fundamental rights is only one side of the issue. The second, no less important problem is that we do not have a system that would help these people exercise their rights. If a person has a mental health problem, objectively, he may need support, including in the decision-making process. This is not a mechanism to make decisions for people, but to help people make their own decisions, which does not exist in Armenia.

“There are mechanisms for incapacity or decision-making on behalf of a person in many countries. Until recent years, this mechanism was very common, however, when the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities was adopted, which clearly states that all people are equal before the law, and states must create tools that will help people realize their capacity, mechanisms that we call decision-making support mechanisms were developed and implemented in a number of countries. These allow a person to choose trusted people who will help them make decisions. Moreover, depending on that decision, the supporters can be different. At any time, a person can refuse this support or change the person they trust. Another system is the mechanism of advance directives, when a person, when in a more stable mental state, gives written instructions regarding their future life, for example, when due to a worsening of their health condition, the decisions they made may not be in their best interests,” says Chilingaryan.
According to the specialist, the mechanism for recognizing a person as incompetent is viewed by the state as a measure of care, while it is an excessive intervention, as a result of which a person is deprived of their rights.
However, in this case, too, the situation must be viewed from two sides: people who are not recognized by the court as incompetent, but who need support, also remain on the sidelines. They are generally forgotten about, since no support mechanism currently exists in Armenia. The rights of these people can also be violated in the form of the disposal of their property, their exploitation, and other types of abuse.
“Recognizing incapacity can no longer be a means of care. This stage must be left in the past,” says Anahit Chilingaryan.

Today, Vahagn is trying to regain his ability to work. He is still in the initial stage of the process, searching for documents. He says he knows it will take a long time, but he is ready to endure. After regaining his ability to work, Vahagn plans to stay in the Spitak nursing home for some time, working with psychologists. He says he still has one problem: he spends the money he has very quickly. However, Vahagn is still alone in this process. He hopes that a lawyer will help him regain his ability to work and live his only life the way he wants.
“The process of restoring legal capacity is a mechanism for ensuring the dignity of a person, recognizing their fullness before the law, which is a serious achievement of the judicial system, but at the same time, this can also be problematic: people whose right to legal capacity is restored may still need support, while the lack of mechanisms to support decision-making leaves them out of social and other support systems. It should be remembered that people with mental health problems, like any of us, can make wrong decisions. A person should not be deprived of the right to make wrong decisions and their wrongness should not be considered only as a consequence of their mental health condition. At the same time, the task of the system should be to form such mechanisms that will help people not make decisions that will lead to the most unfavorable consequences for them or those dependent on them,” says the mental health law specialist.
Text: Sona Martirosyan
Photos by Piruza Khalapyan
This publication was made possible thanks to the support of the Open Society Foundations – Armenia. The views and analyses contained in the publication reflect the opinions of the authors and may not coincide with the views and positions of the Open Society Foundations – Armenia.
Discover more from Disability Rights Agenda
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
